NBA MVP of the Year
Willis Reed - 1970 

NBA Finals MVP
Willis Reed - 1970, 1973
 
All-Star Game MVP
Walt Frazier - 1975
Willis Reed - 1970

NBA Rookie of the Year
Willis Reed - 1965 
Patrick Ewing - 1986 
Mark Jackson - 1988 

NBA Sixth Man of the Year
Anthony Mason - 1995 
John Starks - 1997 
JR Smith - 2013

Defensive Player of the Year
Tyson Chandler - 2012

NBA Coach of the Year
Red Holzman - 1970 
Pat Riley - 1993 
Tom Thibodeau - 2021

All-NBA First Team
Harry Gallatin - 1954 
Walt Frazier - 1970, 1972, 1974, 1975 
Willis Reed - 1970 
Bernard King - 1984 
Patrick Ewing - 1990
 
All-NBA Second Team
Carl Braun - 1948, 1954 
Dick McGuire - 1951 
Harry Gallatin - 1955 
Richie Guerin - 1959, 1960, 1962 
Willis Reed - 1967, 1968, 1969, 1971 
Walt Frazier - 1971, 1973 
Patrick Ewing - 1988, 1989, 1991, 1992, 1993, 1997 
Amare Stoudemire - 2011
Carmelo Anthony - 2013

All-NBA Third Team
Carmelo Anthony -  2012
Tyson Chandler - 2012

NBA All-Defensive First Team
Dave DeBusschere - 1969, 1970, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1974 
Walt Frazier - 1969, 1970, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1974, 1975 
Willis Reed - 1970 
Micheal Ray Richardson - 1981 
Charles Oakley - 1994 
Tyson Chandler - 2013

NBA All-Defensive Second Team
Patrick Ewing - 1988, 1989, 1992 
John Starks - 1993 
Charles Oakley - 1998 
Tyson Chandler - 2012

NBA All-Rookie First Team
Art Heyman - 1964 
Willis Reed - 1965 
Jim Barnes - 1965 
Howard Komives - 1965 
Dick Van Arsdale - 1966 
Cazzie Russell - 1967 
Walt Frazier - 1968 
Phil Jackson - 1968 
Bill Cartwright - 1980 
Darrell Walker - 1984 
Patrick Ewing - 1986 
Mark Jackson - 1988 
Channing Frye - 2006
Landry Fields - 2011
Iman Shumpert - 2012
 
NBA All-Rookie Second Team
Rod Strickland - 1989